A video from Karnataka High Court showing a woman judge questioning the lawyer about his lady client’s demand of getting Rs 6,16,300 per month from her husband as alimony has gone viral on social media platform X (formerly Twitter). The video shows the woman judge rapping the lawyer for the unreasonable alimony demand made by the woman from her divorcing husband.
The hearing of the case was taking place in Karnataka High Court and the recording of the case contains the probing of the lawyer by the judge.
If She Wants To Spend, Let Her Earn
The judge is left surprised after learning that the woman has demanded Rs 6,16,300 from the husband as monthly alimony. The lawyer representing the woman, stands up to defend his client’s demand and also lists the various requirements that the woman mentioned she would be needing money for as her expenses.
The lawyer than reads out the various items enlisted by the woman which includes expensive clothes, money required for food, medicines, and other expenses including branded clothes and eating out which added up to Rs 6,16,300 per month. The judge questioned the list and said that the amount was too high for a single woman without responsibilities and that the husband also had the responsibility to look after the kids.
A Must watch for all Men & Women.
Wife asked 6,16,300/ month as Maintenance, Honorable Judge said that this is exploitation & beyond tolerance. pic.twitter.com/TFjpJ61MHA
— Joker of India (@JokerOf_India) August 21, 2024
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT :
Wife asking for 6,16,000 per month maintenance
4-5 Lacs per month for knee pain, physiotherapy
15000 per month for shoes dresses
60000 per month for food inside home
Few more thousands for dining outside home
JUDGE : ASK HER TO EARN pic.twitter.com/G0LUpIaA33
— Deepika Narayan Bhardwaj (@DeepikaBhardwaj) August 21, 2024
Wife was demanding monthly maintenance of 6 lacs 16 thousand 3 hundred per month only but the lady Judge of the Karnataka High Court disappointed her. And the Wife is demanding this amount even when the children are with the husband and he only is taking care of the expenses of… pic.twitter.com/o7tYXIQK9t
— NCMIndia Council For Men Affairs (@NCMIndiaa) August 21, 2024
What Does The Supreme Court Say On Alimony
The Supreme Court has maintained that the award of maintenance or permanent alimony should not be penal (punishment), and that it should be based on the idea of ensuring a decent standard of living for the wife.
The Supreme Court of India has set the benchmark of 25% of a husband’s net monthly salary as the amount to be paid or given to a wife in monthly alimony payments. However, one-time settlements have no benchmark. As per practice, the amount usually ranges from 1/5th to 1/3rd of the net worth of husband.
